rebuild or replace engine?
#1
rebuild or replace engine?
Question: will any 4 cyl (same product years same model (accord)) swap straight over? currently has a v-tec engine.
Reason: Daughters 96 accord died yesterday on the turnpike. loaded it on to a trailer and brought it home.
She heard a loud 'pop' sound but no other sounds/noises outside the norm.
had someone crank the engine while looking into the tappet cover with a flash light and there was no movement of lifters.
I am thinking broken timing belt. I am guessing there may be a/some bent valves and possibly some piston/cylinder damage.
What kind of actual damage could I be looking at, considering there is no grinding,crunching metal sounds?
She can pickup a motor at salvage for around $150 if we pull it.
No idea how much to repair the existing engine.
Salavge yard engines vary greatly and there may or may not be any vtec engines, and that is why I asked the question above.
I have never worked on a Honda before and really have no idea what to expect here.
Any help/guidance will be greatly appreciated.
Thanks
Reason: Daughters 96 accord died yesterday on the turnpike. loaded it on to a trailer and brought it home.
She heard a loud 'pop' sound but no other sounds/noises outside the norm.
had someone crank the engine while looking into the tappet cover with a flash light and there was no movement of lifters.
I am thinking broken timing belt. I am guessing there may be a/some bent valves and possibly some piston/cylinder damage.
What kind of actual damage could I be looking at, considering there is no grinding,crunching metal sounds?
She can pickup a motor at salvage for around $150 if we pull it.
No idea how much to repair the existing engine.
Salavge yard engines vary greatly and there may or may not be any vtec engines, and that is why I asked the question above.
I have never worked on a Honda before and really have no idea what to expect here.
Any help/guidance will be greatly appreciated.
Thanks
#2
a replacement motor needs to be V-Tec for the computer to work correctly.
Fixing your motor shouldn't be too bad.
Pull the head - bring to machine shop to be rebuilt - reinstall with new belts.
When you pull the head you will need to look for damage to the pistons which sometimes (not often) happens.
If pistons are damaged - replacing the motor with a used motor would be best route.
IMHO - YMMV
Fixing your motor shouldn't be too bad.
Pull the head - bring to machine shop to be rebuilt - reinstall with new belts.
When you pull the head you will need to look for damage to the pistons which sometimes (not often) happens.
If pistons are damaged - replacing the motor with a used motor would be best route.
IMHO - YMMV
#4
to replace engine its faster and more cheaper to do that .ones of my mechanic told me wen the engine build not one thousand of them its build with the same tool. same speed same worker same torque tided bolts for all parts so the u choice .i was replace on my audi quatro 2.3 litr. engine with the same engine and forget abouth that.the partner rebuild crankshaft parts which the bottom of the spend week of work.after try to start the engine they get noise from top which was bent valve on the top .so he spend double money on repair and loose time .that's from my my experience
What does this sentence mean?
"the partner rebuild crankshaft parts which the bottom of the spend week of work"
Please if you are going to respond to someone try to be somewhat clear with your response.
#5
Im also in a replace or repair situation. If you can get a good deal on the engine then go for it. but you also have to take into consideration that the belt on the used engine will probably need to be replaced as well. It's a tough call. you might be better off buying an used engine from someone who removes them and services them ad then sells them. this way you know its good to go.
#6
Im also in a replace or repair situation. If you can get a good deal on the engine then go for it. but you also have to take into consideration that the belt on the used engine will probably need to be replaced as well. It's a tough call. you might be better off buying an used engine from someone who removes them and services them ad then sells them. this way you know its good to go.
Thanks
#8
my suggestion is to do a leakage test that way you will know for sure if there is any bent valves ,, i have seen many t-belt brake and DO not bent valves
if no damage ,than all you got to worry about is replacing the timing belt Kit ( t-belt, balancer belt , water pump, seals, etc etc )
if no damage ,than all you got to worry about is replacing the timing belt Kit ( t-belt, balancer belt , water pump, seals, etc etc )
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post